Brooklyn New York Pizza

251 West Central Street, Natick, MA 01760

Adjacent to the West Natick MBTA Station, Brooklyn Pizza is a welcome addition to the West Central Street Pizza Mile. Hopefully Brooklyn pizza can pick up the slack on that side of town. Best part of its location is you can order up a pie 15 minutes before you leave Jam Time, it will be ready to go and still be warm when you get home for wine'o'clock.


Plenty of pizza options, plenty of fried food options, and plenty of sandwich/sub options. I remember a buffalo chicken sandwich being decent, but maybe that was old ownership, as it is no longer on the menu. Also, they have a kid's menu, which is different for the traditional sub shop.

What to order: Pizza

If the old Natalie's cook bought the joint, as it is rumored, then the pizza is what you want. Natalie's operated a pizza stove at an all-star level.

For Brooklyn, either the Queens or the Florentine.

Final thoughts on

If the pizza can live up to Natalie's quality and fame, then I'm sold.

Brooklyn New York Pizza Hours

Monday 10am - 10pm
Tuesday 10am - 10pm
Wednesday 10am - 10pm
Thursday 10am - 10pm
Friday 10am - 10pm
Saturday 10am - 10pm
Sunday 11am - 9pm